WizardPins Reviews

WizardPins has an overall rating of 3.3 based on 26 reviews. Customer feedback on WizardPins is mixed.

3.3/5.0

26 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

4

1 Star

5

All WizardPins Reviews (26)
hello_jacquelyne090
June 03, 2026
"Minimum order felt like my issue to deal with"
The minimum order requirement was really frustrating. There wasn’t much flexibility, and it kind of felt like they made it my problem instead of trying to work with me.
Robert_bowman89
May 18, 2026
"I’ve ordered from wizardpins a few different times..."
I’ve ordered from wizardpins a few different times now, and the pins have been really consistent overall. The little line details come through clean, the colors are pretty much spot on, and the backs feel sturdy when you pin them on. One batch had a couple of tiny rough edges if you looked closely, but it wasn’t anything that bothered me. Overall, I’ve been happy with the quality...
JulianShakespeare
May 02, 2026
"I was disappointed when the pins arrived..."
I was disappointed when the pins arrived because the tiny details in my artwork just didn’t come through. The lines looked blurry, i feel like the production team didn’t handle the artwork carefully enough. They ended up not matching what I sent over at all.
KathyMoore
April 20, 2026
"I’ve had these on my backpack..."
I’ve had these on my backpack for months now and they’re still looking Totally fine. i’m impressed they’ve held up this well with daily use.
Richard-zeigler
April 12, 2026
"Easy order, great design help"
I needed a little help cleaning up my pin design, and the wizardpins team handled it really quickly. Relief. They kept the original idea intact but made it work better for printing, which I appreciated. The back and forth was super easy, with no weird upsells or confusing steps. Nice. The pins showed up looking just like the proof. Solid experience overall, and I’d definitely order again.
audreyfrank9969
March 26, 2026
"My pins made their grand entrance exactly..."
My pins made their grand entrance exactly on the day they promised. The tracking worked without any chaos, which was a relief. It wasn’t lightning-fast or anything, but the delivery was smooth and pleasantly drama-free.
david_Bruce72
March 26, 2026
"They got the issue fixed pretty..."
They got the issue fixed fast and the process was easy enough, which I do appreciate. That said, it still caused me some inconvenience, so I’m expecting some kind of compensation or credit for the trouble
Vicki.cottle
March 19, 2026
"Bad timing made the whole refund process even more annoying"
The pins showed up wrong, which was already frustrating, but the timing made it worse because I needed them sooner. Getting it sorted out took way too much back and forth over email. They did eventually offer a replacement, but not until after a bunch of messages, and the refund option felt slow too. It wasn’t the absolute worst experience, but it was definitely more of a hassle than it needed to be.
hello_luis767
March 19, 2026
"Proofing took way too long"
The proofing process was way more frustrating than it should’ve been. They messed up my proof twice, and after I had already paid, I started feeling like I couldn’t really trust that they were paying attention or taking it seriously. It just dragged on longer than expected and left me uneasy about the whole experience.
hello_robert589
March 16, 2026
"Quick Replies and No Hassle"
They got back to me fast whenever I had questions and kept me in the loop the whole time. made the order feel super easy and stress-Free.
corey.Thelen
March 07, 2026
"I ordered a small batch of..."
I ordered a small batch of pins the price was... fine. It felt fair for what I ended up getting, just not the cheapest option I came across, and not wildly expensive either.
The thing is, the extra options and add-ons started adding up faster than I expected, so I kept going back and tweaking my order. Overall, it was alright, I just wish the final price had been more obvious from the beginning.
loislittle8914
March 07, 2026
"I really loved how many custom options there..."
I really loved how many custom options there were for the pins. It made it easy to get my design looking exactly the way I imagined. When I finally saw the finished result, I was so happy, it felt really special to see my idea come to life.
john-Czarnota
February 24, 2026
"Showed up quicker than I thought"
These arrived way faster than I was expecting. I had kind of planned to be waiting around for a bit, but they showed up before I even got around to clearing space for them. I was actually in the middle of reorganizing a drawer—one of those tasks that somehow takes over your whole afternoon, when they got here. So yeah, quick turnaround and no annoying waiting
Phyllis.lyons
February 17, 2026
"I ordered some pins from WizardPins, and overall..."
I ordered some pins from WizardPins, and overall it worked okay. Like, I got through it without too much trouble, but it wasn’t the smoothest thing ever.

The upload part was easy, but I had to keep going back and checking stuff like sizes and options because I wasn’t totally sure what I picked. A couple pages loaded kind of slow too, and I had that feeling where you’re like, did my change actually save or not?

So yeah, not a bad experience, just a little rough around the edges. I didn’t have to message support or anything, and I did get the order placed, so I guess it did the job...
hello_louis508
February 16, 2026
"Packaging held up really well"
When my order showed up, I was relieved to see the box looking neat and in good shape. I opened it up and all the pins were safe inside with no dents or damage, so the packaging definitely did its job.
robertryan9814
February 03, 2026
"Pins were fine at first glance, but the quality wasn’t great"
I ordered a small batch of enamel pins from WizardPins and at first they looked decent enough, the colors were close to what I expected and nothing was wildly off, but once I actually started going through the bag I noticed a few had rough edges and tiny scratches already on them which was kind of frustrating.
Some of the pin backs felt a little loose too and since I was planning to sell these at a local event that made me nervous, they weren’t the worst pins I’ve ever gotten or anything, but for what I paid I really thought they’d be cleaner and more consistent.
lester.Raines
January 25, 2026
"Wow. The colors came out just right and..."
Wow. The colors came out just right and it looked exactly like the file I sent over. Nice...
EvelynRiecke
January 23, 2026
"Pretty decent, still deciding"
The pins were decent overall. I might order them again at some point, though I’m not totally sure yet. They looked fine and did the job, but I’m still kind of going back and forth on whether I’d reorder.
jackthorne8580
December 24, 2025
"I ordered a bulk batch of pins for..."
I ordered a bulk batch of pins for our club, and overall it was just okay. The pricing seemed fair, but the sorting was a bit messy and the shipping updates weren’t very clear. I also wasn’t sure what the next steps were half the time, which got frustrating when I was trying to plan around the order. A few pins had small flaws too. Customer support did help fix part of the issue, but it took longer than I expected.
troy_Young71
December 22, 2025
"Way too expensive for what it is"
I really wanted to like this, and at first I thought maybe it would be worth the price. But honestly? No. It just feels overpriced for what you actually get, and I wouldn’t buy it again.

View More Reviews

Have a question about WizardPins?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.